Art Songs

\begin{array}{l l} \text{Parlo d'amor vegliando,} & \text{Whatsoe'er I am doing,} \\ \text{Parlo d'amor sognando,} & \text{Whatsoe'er I'm pursuing,} \\ \text{All' acqua, all' ombra, ai monti,} & \text{In sunshine or in showers,} \\ \text{Ai fiori, all' erbe, ai fonti, ...} & \text{At home or midst the flowers, ...} \\ \text{All' ecco---all' aria---a venti,} & \text{I sigh---I pant---I languish,} \\ \text{Che il suon de vani accenti, ...} & \text{In bliss that throbs like anguish, ...} \\ \end{array}

Sung by the pubescent, flirtatious Cherubino (he’s played by a soprano), these words are notable for their arresting meter and rhyme, the heavenly beauty of their melody, and, well, their humor. Mozart’s The Marriage of Figaro—recently performed fantastically by the Peabody Opera Theater—presents such an explosive combination of theatricality, musicality, and hilarity as to make Mozart come across as a supernatural genius.

Only later did I learn that Mozart did not work alone [1]. The Felix Krull-esque French man-of-the-world Pierre Beaumarchais originally wrote the French play Le Mariage de Figaro in 1784; only then did Lorenzo Da Ponte, an equally fascinating Italian librettist, translate the play into Italian, excise a tirade against inherited nobility (thus making the play acceptable to the censors), and set certain of its passages to meter and rhyme. These developments, finally, prepared the way for Mozart to set music to the entire work, which premiered in 1786. The libretto’s rhymed passages became the opera’s arias.

This realization, in fact, placed Mozart into a long tradition within classical music.

Nowhere is this tradition better exemplified than in the world of Lieder, in which historic German poems are set anew to music featuring just a single voice and a single piano. Though Lieder has a long history, it thrived in the Romantic era of the late 18th and early 19th centuries [2]. Robert Schumann, in particular, emerged as a prolific composer of Lieder, and, though many poets appeared in his works, chief among them was the legendary Jewish German Romantic poet Heinrich Heine.

I’ve become especially interested in the Romanzen und Balladen of Schumann’s Liederkreis, Op. 24., a collection of Lieder works composed using poems drawn from Heine’s Buch der Lieder, itself written in 1827. These include Die beiden Grenadiere, in which Schumann concludes Heine’s fiery tribute to French patriotism with a tongue-in-cheek musical quotation of La Marseillaise, as well as Belsatzar, in which Heine’s wrenching rendition of the Old Testament story from the Book of Daniel is made all the more haunting by Schumann’s sensitive musical touch. Also noteworthy are Abends am Strand, where fisherman gaze out to the sea and tell stories, and Die fiendlichen Bruder, a poignant tale of two feuding brothers.

*                *                *

“This kinda sucks,” Josh once told me, after I showed him a Lied set to orchestra. “It’s just not that pleasant to listen to.” While Lob des Hohen Verstandes may be, grantedly, more entertaining than pleasant, Josh has responded with similar encouragement to most of the Lieder I’ve shown him. I often find myself turning to the same response: You have to listen to it with the lyrics.

This exchange, in my view, exhibits something important about Lieder. I haven’t tried listening to Mozart’s Figaro separated from its visual staging, from the lilt of its rhymes, and the from meanings of its words—but I’m not particularly inclined to try. The opera, despite its separate parts and their disparate origins, is fundamentally one work of art. To deprive it of some or all of its parts would be a disservice.

In Lieder, likewise, multiple parts (typically, again, from different sources) come together to yield the final work of art. I can name a few of these:

  1. The story. Though sometimes invented by the poet, the stories used in Lieder poems are often based on old folk stories, if not biblical ones.
  2. The poetry. The poet—for example, Heine—adds to these stories immaculate and pleasing meter and rhyme.
  3. The music. Finally, the composer, in our case Schumann, superimposes music, which itself comprises melody as well as subtler features like dynamics and tempo.

It is the simultaneous combination of these many features, I contend, that makes Lieder exquisitely pleasing. Every word of a Lied’s poem is sung using subtle and shifting dynamics, wrapping together its story into a dramatic and consuming—and entirely musical—experience. These three aspects speak together in a very strong language.

The word Lieder is typically translated into English as Art Songs. No reduction to constituent parts can account for Lieder’s brilliance, however, and in this piece I have used only the original word.


  1. The Marriage of Figaro, Encyclopedia Brittanica
  2. Lied, Encyclopedia Brittanica

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s